January 2025 Market Recap—Will This Year Bring More Opportunities or Challenges?

Southwest Colorado’s real estate market started 2025 with higher inventory, longer days on market, and steady price appreciation. While the market remains active, shifting dynamics suggest a more balanced environment where buyers have increased leverage.

Let’s break down the latest numbers and what they mean for the regional housing market.

January 2025 Market Overview

Key Takeaways: Understanding the Market Shift

Inventory is growing, but it remains below historic norms. The 814 active listings reflect a 4.4% increase from 2024, providing buyers with more options. However, while inventory is rising, it is still well below pre-pandemic levels, which helps keep upward pressure on prices.

Homes are sitting on the market longer before selling. The average days on market (DOM) increased to 162, up 21.9% from 2024. Higher-priced counties, such as San Miguel (204 DOM) and Ouray (267 DOM), are seeing slower movement, indicating that demand for luxury properties may be cooling.

Luxury home sales are distorting price averages. The $1.27M regional average home price is heavily influenced by San Miguel County’s $4.5M average price. Excluding this luxury-heavy area, the true median home price in most counties remains below $1M, making homes more accessible to a broader range of buyers.

Sales volume remains steady despite changing market conditions. A total of 136 homes sold in January 2025, marking a 13.3% year-over-year increase. La Plata (46 sales) and Montrose (45 sales) led the region in transaction volume, showing continued buyer activity in those counties.

Buyers are gaining leverage as competition cools. Longer time on market and increased inventory mean sellers may need to adjust pricing strategies to attract buyers. The shift in the market dynamics suggests that buyers now have more room for negotiation, particularly in luxury and mid-range price points.

Regional Market Insights: Durango, Pagosa Springs, and Bayfield

Durango continues to be one of the most sought-after locations in Southwest Colorado. The average home price rose 12% YOY to $966,391, signaling steady demand. Homes in Durango are spending 91 days on market (down from 107 in 2024), suggesting buyers are still actively purchasing despite higher interest rates. Additionally, active listings increased to 180, up 7.8% YOY, creating more choices for buyers.

Pagosa Springs is seeing a slight cooling in its market, with home prices dropping 7.2% YOY to $584,460. The 133 days on market (compared to 144 in 2024) suggests that while homes are still moving, the pace has slowed. Inventory is also increasing, with active listings rising by 10.8%, meaning buyers have more selection and negotiation power than in previous years.

Bayfield remains one of the more affordable options in the region, but the market is moving at a slower pace. Home prices rose 3.2% YOY to $476,322, showing moderate appreciation. However, days on market increased to 164 (from 114 in 2024), indicating that buyers are taking more time to make decisions. Additionally, active listings jumped 32.1%, a significant increase in supply that could lead to more price adjustments in the coming months.

What This Means for Buyers and Sellers

For buyers, the market is offering more choices, with rising inventory providing greater flexibility. Homes are sitting on the market longer, which could translate to better deals and room for negotiation. Buyers looking at high-end properties in San Miguel and Ouray will find that these listings are staying on the market much longer, potentially creating opportunities for price reductions.

For sellers, competitive pricing is becoming increasingly important. Overpricing could lead to extended market times, as buyers now have more negotiating power. Luxury home sellers, in particular, may need to adjust expectations, as high-end properties are moving slower than in previous years. However, with interest rate stability expected in 2025, buyer activity could pick up in the spring, making this a crucial time to prepare listings strategically.

Final Thoughts: A Market Shifting Toward Balance

The Southwest Colorado real estate market is no longer a pure seller’s market, as buyers are gaining leverage with longer DOM and rising inventory. However, home values remain resilient, and certain counties, like Durango, continue to see strong demand.

Sellers should price competitively to attract serious buyers, while buyers can take advantage of increasing inventory for better deals.

For further details on market trends and to explore opportunities in Southwest Colorado, feel free to contact me. Let’s navigate these changing times together and find the best deals tailored to your needs.

Stay informed! Fill out the form below to SUBSCRIBE to our weekly newsletter!